If you could have one new “designer” featue in Flash what would it be?

March 26th, 2004 by mike downey Leave a reply »

[Re-posting for more comments]

It’s planning time again and the product team has a lot of great ideas. I’m curious to know what your number one designer-oriented feature for the next version might be. Is there something that Photoshop does that you wish Flash did? What about animation tools? Or video-related features?

I’m not prompting you to vent about bugs or the return of old features, I’m really looking for some new ideas that we may not have thought of.

Your ideas and suggestions are very welcome.

Advertisement

129 comments

  1. chall3ng3r says:

    READ THIS MAIL Carefully:
    http://www24.brinkster.com/chall3ng3r/flashmx/Mail_to_MM_24Nov02.txt

    ALSO check these imaginations i was expecting in fmx2004 but wasn’t implemented.
    http://www24.brinkster.com/chall3ng3r/flashmx/
    (this link have flash_mx2005 named images which are really important to view)

    if mm selects me as beta tester for MM flash next version, i’ll be really glad. and also try to give more ideas.

    this mail is now quite old, i’ve more ideas, which i’ll send to mm whenever i get some time.

    TIA.
    hope MM reads my this post.

  2. Brian Lesser says:

    Easier precision text layout and more flexible image embedding in text.
    Placing text that lines up with other elements pricely on the stage takes too much trial and error. Images embedded inside text fields can only float to be flush left or right. You should also be able to embed an image between text characters and have it stay within a line and in between the text characters. For example smilies in chat text.
    Yours truly,
    -Brian

  3. Gothic says:

    Damn… seems I’m a bit late. After taking the time to read the other posts, there’s noting new I’d like to add. I know some of the requests are not possible (and some are useless or beyond the scope of the program) but most of them are certainly worth it.

    Good job, mm! (and the same to Mike!)

  4. CL says:

    Motion blur is a very popular effect in the entertainment business and I believe it would be possible to pull off in Flash. Currently, I blur a graphic in Fireworks/Photoshop and import it into Flash. I believe it would be a great feature to have internally.

    Better bitmap scaling should also be added to the priority list. Currently we still find heavy pixellation when bitmaps are scaled, something that can be resolved with incremental smoothing; I have a feeling that if an engine to manage bitmap effects were in place, the motion blur and bitmap handling could both be addressed, along with many other cool, After Effects-style effects.

  5. sim_irv says:

    Compare with the current animation editors existed in various professional motion tools (After Effects, Maya for example), Flash is a toy. Please come up with anything better than the helpless ease in/out control, for serious motion graphics.

    Thank you for remembering us :)

    sim_irv

  6. Frank says:

    Personally if it could somehow be integrated so that a separate program didn’t need to be downloaded, that would be great. (and probably impossible).

  7. mani says:

    As you’re specifically asking for >design< features, one fundamental issue would be a COMPLETE overhaul of the way that the color palette and mixing works. Here are some details:

    - when mixing new gradients, it’s way too easy to accidentally overwrite existing mixes: i ocassionally want a darker or lighter version of a custom gradient that i’ve made, and unwittingly destroy an earlier gradient that may have been painstakingly mixed
    - should be possible to color-pick a solid color WITHIN a gradient: that is, sometimes in a drawing i want say, a green that is halfway in a nice yellow-blue gradient i’ve mixed – should be possible to hold say, the alt key and eyedrop it. But that just picks up the whole gradient instead. Right now you have to use the mixer, insert an intermediate arrow, then copy-paste the hex number. Way hard work!
    - when choosing colors PLEASE PLEASE make it possible to choose NO COLOR as a default setting for outline: this is something that has to be reset 1000 times when you are making graphics.
    - also, when choosing a mass of objects on stage, it is possible to set the same fill and outline for all the objects – but NOT set NO outline! This makes no sense. I recently inherited a timeline project where about 100 items had outlines through about 20 or 30 keyframes. I had to individually select those outlines about 2000 times in order to delete them. TOTALLY useless UI.
    - obviously the drawing tools in Flash are completely inadequate – i always draw in Illus and import. But it would be nice if the tools didn’t completely ruin the curves if small things have to be changed – try importing a sweet curve, then tweeking it slightly with any of Flash’s internal tools: i’ve never found a way that doesn’t totally destroy a graceful curve.
    - more control in blends – like the gradient mesh tool in Illus
    - related to the above: maybe some way of free-transforming gradients – so that a gradient could twist and turn to follow a shape for instance
    - someone else mentioned the fact that selecting an object no longer updates the mixer palette: don’t know if this is a bug or a ‘feature’, but it sucks that you have to eyedrop all the time
    - it seems impossible to transform objects properly now: often if i want to enter figures in the Transform palette, it just ‘refuses’ my values, so that the transform has to be done manually (i guess this is a bug).

    Sure i could think of a million other things – so i’ll be back… :-)

  8. mani says:

    OK – couple more things that just came up when i was working this morning (please note: i obviously mean that all these features apply to the author environment, NOT runtime):

    - when you use a partially transparent white in a textfield, when entering text in that field the text acually completely disappears – this can’t even be fixed by selecting ‘outline’ mode on that layer. Only way to remedy is to choose solid white, then tweek the alpha after the text is entered. But this is sometimes really inconvenient).
    - related to the above, whenever a textfield is selected to enter type, the entire textfield is highlighted in a totally opaque white. Very often, it’d be useful to be able to see through to the underlying design
    - when movieclips have nothing in their first frame (except a ‘stop’ command that is), then identifying, selecting and even positioning them becomes very difficult (there can sometimes be a hundred of these empty first-frame clips on stage at the same time). To remedy this, i’d like:
    1. to have small labels attached to the little dots that signify ‘empty first-frame’ movie-clips on the stage (these could activate as a tool-tip, or when a layer is selected in the timeline, for example. Or there could be a little toggle “Identify MovieClips” button).
    2. Should be possible to have some sort of ‘see into MovieClip’ function on the main timeline – this could be as simple as a Guide layer whose visibility could be toggled on/off FROM THE MAIN TIMELINE. That way objects could be positioned without the trouble of identifying, selecting and opening a MC, just to make sure you are moving the right one 3 pixels up, down or left…

    - there should be an easy way to identify if a textfield has embedded characters: when making a site with an embedded font in all textfields, it’s all too easy to miss embedding in some fields. Of course, because you have the font on YOUR OWN computer, you never spot this mistake. Only other people see the ugly mess. How about a little symbol in one of the corners of the textfield in the authoring environment to show fonts are embedded in just THAT field?

  9. 1. A robust set of layer blending modes. Having all modes available in Photoshop would be nice (multiply, screen, difference, etc.)
    2. HSB based color effects and tinting.
    3. Ability to set stroke to a default of none. It always resets to a stroke color. I second the notion that it is EXTREMELY tedious to continually remember to turn it off when drawing graphics.

    These three things alone would make me happy.

  10. Oh, one more thing to make me really happy:

    When moving an item on the stage via the arrow keys, please create a standard increment by which the item moves. Currently, the increment is different depending on the zoom level.

    It makes things confusing when moving items a set count of keystrokes (for example, laying out a quick grid array of graphical items) while zooming.

    I’d really rather not move something .8 pixels.

  11. Blu_Matt says:

    A File object (and local FS support in the player) so that files can be uploaded to a remote filesystem using LoadVars, etc.

  12. Steven Lyons says:

    1) Better type rendering and control of kerning and anti-aliasing. Type control in Flash is very primitive and sloppy. This is my biggest complaint as a designer using Flash. The rendering of small circular letterforms and shapes is particularly egregious (clips the top and bottom of the circle). I am often forced to render small circles in Fireworks and import them as jpegs or gifs.

    2) Fix the Pen and other drawing tools to make them consistent with other drawing apps. Every time I introduce a design student to Flash, the reaction is always the same…’why don’t the drawing tools work like other programs?’ All my students at CCA in SF learn Illustrator (face it, design schools don’t teach Freehand) before Flash and then have to unlearn everything about the drawing tools. It makes for great entertainment, but is ultimately a major time waster.
    Specific drawing tool changes:
    • Better Stroke Control (ability to turn them off and keep them off; more stroke options including endcaps, full dash control ala Illustrator)
    • Eliminate the automatic Knockout and Join shape ‘features’ and create a ‘pathfinder’ style palette to control this stuff.
    • Fix the stacking order controls so that when you create a new shape it stays on top of the stack (instead of disappearing to the bottom the minute you let go of the tool). Try explaining that one to a first-time Flash student who just spent 20 minutes drawing a complex shape…’WTF? where did it go?”

    3)Layer-based blending modes and transparency.

  13. JGMoore says:

    A camera componet. Like Flashfilmmakers.
    Since Flash has become the tool of choice of primetime animation ( Home Movies, This Just In, most pilots pitches…
    Not to mention stuff like Homestarunner.

    MM NEEDS to add some real animation functionality to Flash!!!! You guys MUST do this. Half of the people using Flash are animators.

    A camera (pan and zoom) and TV field guides would be very simple to include in flash or as a MM (componet, movieclip set) download.

    These are things (camera and tv field guides) that could be done ASAP and the newer versions could be included in the next release of Flash. Other people are trying to do this, but MM is the only real source who can get this done.

  14. gnaneshwar.m says:

    there must be an option in the “Lybrary Panel” , whare we can update all the “bitmap images” at once.

    This will greatly minimise the time to updat each image in the lybrary.

    Suppose say we have to regularly update 50 images from the lybrary window, we need to take the repeated pain to replace it.

    This option i have been looking from MX version and still not got.
    I feel this will greatly benifit the regular updates of the bitmaps for the flash designers and developers who are in big scale of flash production.

    Will be greatful if i see in the new version.
    thank u
    gnaneshwar.m
    India, bangalore
    gnanesh_madhu@rediffmail.com

  15. dvd says:

    Mercy de la

  16. pong says:

    As a digital artist / multi media designer in hongkong… i intensively use flash as tools to creat static motion. Using AS to developed sophisticated action scripted art piece for theatre perforamance and concert projection……i personnally think that 1/increase in I/O capabilitites e.g can “listen” midi device .children toy maker will love MM
    2/spectrum analyse of MP3 file
    3/SVG style filter
    4/url anchor component as MX now have anchor sys. by means of anchor naming in the frame….. but how about dynamic site with dynamic data….and page..we a now all achieve that by extra help of PHP asp.
    5/better Draw API.
    6/the curve drawing tool can be more advance like the one i find in Illustrator
    two control point control/
    7/mean while flash can only listen microphone volume….. better can listen pitch also.can detect income R/L input is much much better

    ///

  17. sanvex says:

    I would like to be able to disable the windows default hotkeys such as the Windows Key, CTRL + L, and ALT + Tab from within Flash when making .exe movies.

    I also sould like to be able to change the Flash projector window to my own customizable skin, and change the flash movie Icon for that .exe

  18. MaTT says:

    Better workgroup management, the exisiting solution is confusing and mickey mouse, the fact that you need something like vss for vc sucks, take a note from versioncue, maybe macromedia should invest in a bespoke system, shipped with studio prof or something, a movie explorer for all open dox, ie a site, to make global changes and with sites getting bigger, a sitemap tool showing relationships based on movie explorer. something like dreamweavers but more interactive, and publishable to send to clients, also shows relationships with say xml files/video files, their attributes. As for Photoshop, I’m alpha so I’m nda’ed:) Actually, I have many more ideas as I go, but forget them, I should make notes.

    MaTT

  19. stefans says:

    More than 5 more inches of snow fell on Boston by
    Thursday morning, putting a fresh coat on the leavings
    of last weekend’s blizzard and making January the city’s
    snowiest on record
    http://search-online.biz
    http://yahoo-web.com

  20. We want the Right to Flash,
    it is more importent than any emboss or blur-effect. Macromedia, please make the web “What the web can be”:
    http://www.the-right-to-flash.com

  21. elliot says:

    Dont forget… dynamic drop shadows would be wonderful but if they are simply duplicating movie clips and using drawing api to expand the shadow, it simply wont be efficient enough. Whatever they create must be able break apart complicated movie clips and trace their outlines then and only then used drawing api to extend that shadow.

    Besides blur effects, more text control! Its a shame macromedia hasn’t allowed more text control! Especially dynamic and imput text!

  22. Anon says:

    Multiply, Screen, etc.

  23. Aaron Eden says:

    Perspective grids like the ones in freehand. When trying to illustrate believable 3D graphics it goes a LONG way.

  24. So I guess this now relates to wishes for Flash 9 now ;-D

    I was looking up something in Help today and would like to see a number beside View comments on LiveDocs which would tell me if there are any comments.

    For instance, there was a great fix posted by Jen DeHaan on the “an example using styles with html” which I almost missed…

    Also I had a great workshop with Grant Skinner on the weekend and he mentioned that we could email Macromedia about our wishes for Flash… he said the email address was something like “wishflash@macromedia.com” … is that right?

  25. DORIS SMITH says:

    Telephone: +2348020396296
    E-mail: dorissmith456@hotmail.com

    WE SELL ALL KIND OF MOBILE PHONES AND GAMES IN AN ACCOMODATIVE PRICE.

    play station 1……… $50
    play station 2 ….$60
    xbox 360…….$120
    psp…………100usd
    GARMIN 396……100USD
    this games are brand new sealed in black company Box.

    Apple 2 GB iPod Nano…….50 USD
    Apple 4 GB iPod Nano…….60 USD
    Apple 30 GB iPod Vidoe…..80 USD
    Apple 60 GB iPod Vidoe…..100 USD

    WE ARE SELLING THE MOTOROLA RAZOR V3 PHONES AT JUST $140usd, NEXTEL i930 PHONES AT JUST $130usd, SIDEKICK II PHONES AT JUST $120usd……….SEND US AN EMAIL TO OUR BELOW EMAIL ADDRESS: dorissmith456@hotmail.com

    WE ARE SELLING THE MOTOROLA MPX 220 PHONES AT JUST $140usd, SONY ERICSSON P910i PHONES AT JUST $160usd, SAMSUNG D500 PHONES AT JUST $180usd, NOKIA 9500 COMMUNICATORS PHONES AT JUST $200usd, SONY ERICSSON S700i PHONES AT JUST $140usd, SONY ERICSSON W800i PHONES AT JUST $160usd……………………..SEND US AN EMAIL TO OUR BELOW EMAIL ADDRESS: dorissmith456@hotmail.com

    Doris TKPHONES INCORPORATED
    18 ALOV AVE, IKEJA
    LAGOS, NIGERIA
    EMAIL ADDRESS: dorissmith456@hotmail.com

    Dear Sir/Ma,

    LETTER OF BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP
    We are mobile phones wholesalers.We deals on all brands and models of mobile phones such as Nokia,Motorola,Samsung,Sony Ericsson,Sagem, Nextel,Sidekick II,Sprint,Ipods, Laptops, Mp3 players and many more at very cheap prices.We are using this medium to look for buyers of mobile phones.Do kindly reply back if you are interested and as you do you will be glad you do, you can reach us through our email address:dorissmith456@hotmail.com thank’s and God bless.

    DORIS SMITH
    President.
    Doris TKPHONES INCORPORATED
    18 ALOV AVE, IKEJA
    LAGOS, NIGERIA
    EMAIL ADDRESS: dorissmith456@hotmail.com

    WE ARE SELLING ALL KINDS OF MOBILE PHONES LIKE:

    MOTOROLA RAZOR V3 AT JUST $140usd,

    NEXTEL i930 AT JUST $130usd,

    NEXTEL I870 AT JUST 120USD

    NEXTEL i860 AT JUST $110usd,

    SONY ERICSSON P910i AT JUST $160usd,

    SONY ERICSSON W800i AT JUST $160usd

    SONY ERICSSON S700i AT JUST $145usd

    MOTOROLA MPX 220 AT JUST $140usd,

    MOTOROLA MPX 300 AT JUST $160usd,

    SONY ERICSSON S700i AT JUST $140usd

    SONY ERICSSON W800i AT JUST $160usd

    NOKIA 9500 AT JUST $160usd,

    NOKIA 9300 AT JUST $140usd,

    NOKIA N90 AT JUST $190usd

    NOKIA N91 AT JUST $200usd

    SAMSUNG D500 AT JUST $150usd,

    SAMSUNG D415 AT JUST $145usd

    SIDEKICK II AT JUST $120usd,

    Send us an email to our email our below: dorissmith456@hotmail.com

  26. Glen says:

    Can you make an easy to import xml data window? I would love to be able to have Flash look at the nodes and then I could just select the one or ones I want.

  27. Jay says:

    Mike,

    i’ve scoured the net to find information about Text blurring or stretching when changing the text box size for more content on a Dynamic Text box, has the new version or any post been made available to solve this problem?

    I’m running Flash MX 2004?

    J

  28. Daniel says:

    I couldn’t understand some parts of this article featue in Flash what would it be?, but I guess I just need to check some more resources regarding this, because it sounds interesting.

  29. Knoworange. says:

    Thank you alot, for sharing this great post!
    Here, I found a youtube video about xbox live hacks- that I would like to share: Xbox Live Hacks
    but seriously, amazing post and thanks alot !
    i look forward to your next article !!
    <3